Solutions

Platform

Services

Insights

About

Blog

/

May 16, 2022

Carbon Direct and Microsoft Release 2022 Update to the Criteria for High-Quality Carbon Dioxide Removal

Blog

/

May 16, 2022

Carbon Direct and Microsoft Release 2022 Update to the Criteria for High-Quality Carbon Dioxide Removal

Blog

/

May 16, 2022

Carbon Direct and Microsoft Release 2022 Update to the Criteria for High-Quality Carbon Dioxide Removal

Photo of yellow seaweed on a rocky shore
Photo of yellow seaweed on a rocky shore
Photo of yellow seaweed on a rocky shore

Our initial goal was to provide carbon removal project developers with expert guidance to improve the quality of their projects and their resulting removal credits. The impact and success of that document has far exceeded our expectations. It has led to numerous project developers across a range of carbon removal solutions reaching out for further guidance as to how to implement the Criteria. It has also led to corporate buyers of removals wanting to learn more about how they can utilize the Criteria to ensure the highest level of quality in their carbon credit portfolios.

In developing these Criteria, our intent was for them to be part of a living document, to be updated as the science progresses and as the carbon removal market evolves. And the carbon dioxide removal landscape is indeed evolving very rapidly – partly spurred by the recent scientific consensus in the 2022 IPCC 6th Assessment Report that asserts that carbon removals are “essential” to achieving global climate targets.

As such, it is more important than ever that we continue to support the identification and standardization of high-quality criteria for carbon removal – which is why we are excited to release our first Criteria update. This update reflects the latest developments in carbon removal science as well as the new types of projects (like blue carbon) that are demonstrating significant potential for climate impact as part of our clients’ portfolios.

Read The 2022 Criteria For High-Quality Carbon Dioxide Removal Here

“The Criteria for High-Quality Removal provided valuable guidance to project developers that wanted to take part in Microsoft’s procurement efforts or any other corporate purchase,” said Rafael Broze, Carbon Removal Program Manager at Microsoft. “We’re pleased to have Carbon Direct continue to refine those criteria in an effort to strengthen common standards for both developers of projects to follow as well as educate buyers how to identify high-quality projects.”

“Microsoft and Carbon Direct have collaborated on the Criteria for High-Quality Carbon Dioxide Removal for two years now and we greatly value their leadership in maturing this market,” said Jonathan Goldberg, CEO of Carbon Direct. “The carbon removal market needs further standardization and stronger frameworks to take its next step forward and provide assurances to the next wave of buyers that come into this market. This document is a stepping stone to that end goal.”

The most substantial updates to the Criteria this year include:

  • Mangrove Reforestation: Mangrove restoration is gaining traction globally as a carbon removal approach due in part to the co-benefits healthy mangrove ecosystems provide, including helping stabilize coastlines, shelter coastal communities from flooding, and providing nursery habitat for fish. We’ve added criteria specific to high-quality mangrove restoration projects to help inform buyers and project developers interested in this area.

  • Harms & Benefits: We’ve retitled the “Do no harm and pursue co-benefits” section as “Harms and Benefits.” This update was intended to ensure language matches reality. ‘Do no harm’ is an unrealistic bar if taken literally. All projects have consequences, both good and bad, beyond their quantified greenhouse gas impacts. This section acknowledges the complexity of the CO2 removal space, encourages the development of projects with environmental and community benefits, and requires vigorous accounting and remedy of potential project harms.

  • Environmental Justice: We’ve sharpened and streamlined our Environmental Justice criteria to include more vertical specific guidance to further clarify what is expected of project developers.


This Criteria update marks the first of many. Moving forward, Carbon Direct will refresh the Criteria as the carbon removal space matures, keeping pace with the rapidly evolving science and market. We will add new sections as nascent CDR solutions emerge and become more prominent in the market. We will also continually sharpen our guidance on elements of project quality that have proven challenging for project developers, such as how to establish credible Environmental Justice and Climate Justice plans.

Looking ahead, our focus has expanded to include supporting and guiding candidate suppliers not only for Microsoft’s latest procurement cycle, but also for the carbon market more broadly. This is with the recognition that with the integration of this Criteria, carbon markets will be able to facilitate the deployment of high-quality carbon removal at the scale needed to meet our climate goals.

Headshot of Vish Arora, Climate Strategy Associate, on a white background

Vish Arora

Climate Strategy Associate

Shelby Walsh

Shelby Walsh

Carbon Accounting Specialist

Headshot of Jonathan Goldberg

Jonathan Goldberg

CEO + Founder

Headshot of Dr. Matthew Potts on blurred background

Matthew D. Potts, PhD

Chief Science Officer

Headshot of Nili Gilbert on blurred background

Nili Gilbert

Vice Chairwoman

Headshot of Dr. Julio Friedman on blurred background

Julio Friedmann, PhD

Chief Scientist

Danan Margason

Chief Product Officer

Jessica Isaacs

Vice President, Finance

Headshot of Ellie Newnham on white background

Ellie Newnham

Vice President, Business Operations

Headshot of Micah Macfarlane on teal background

Micah Macfarlane

Chief Supply Officer

Headshot of Cale Kennedy on blurred green plants background

Cale Kennedy

Chief Technology Officer

Headshot of Brett Evans on blurred background

Brett Evans

Vice President, Sales

Headshot of Serene Chen outside on white/blue background

Serene Chen

Vice President, People & Culture

Headshot of Rachel Pepple on black background

Rachel Pepple

Vice President, Marketing

Headshot of Christian Braneon on white background

Christian Braneon, PhD

Head of Climate Justice

Headshot of Dr. Colin McCormick on green blurred background

Colin McCormick, PhD

Principal Scientist

Headshot of Dr. Wilfried Maas on plain white background

Wilfried Maas, PhD

Chief Carbon Technology Strategist

Headshot of A.J. Simon on blurred blue background

A.J. Simon

Head of Industrial Decarbonization

Headshot of Alex Dolginow

Alex Dolginow

Headshot of Dr. Erica Belmont on blurred brown background

Erica Belmont, PhD

Principal Decarbonization Engineer

James Burbridge

Director, North America Advisory

Headshot of Dr. Meera Atreya on blurred background

Meera Atreya, PhD

Director of EMEA Advisory & Senior Scientist

Headshot of Dr. Sarah Federman on blurred background

Sarah Federman, PhD

Director of Landscape Decarbonization

Headshot of Van Butsic

Van Butsic, PhD

Principal Scientist

Zara Ahmed, DrPH

Head of Policy & Science Operations

Headshot of Alexandra Peek

Alexandra Peek

Environmental and Climate Justice Strategist

Headshot of Dr. Amy Stuckert on plain gray background

Amy Stuckert, PhD

Senior Decarbonization Engineer

Antaeres Antoniuk-Pablant, PhD

Senior Decarbonization Scientist

Avantika Singh

Senior Carbon Removal Engineer

Headshot of Dr. Bodie Cabiyo on blue blurred background

Bodie Cabiyo, PhD

Senior Forest Scientist

Headshot of Dr. Dan Sanchez on dark background

Dan Sanchez, PhD

Principal Scientist

Emily Kyker-Snowman, PhD

Senior Soil Scientist

Headshot of Hadley Tallackson on background with plants

Hadley Tallackson

Policy Analyst

Headshot of John Dees on blurred background

John Dees, PhD

Senior Decarbonization Scientist

Photo of Dr. Letty Brown outside

Letty Brown, PhD

Senior Forest Scientist

Logan Sander

Forest Scientist

Maria Travaille

Client Engagement Manager

Headshot of Matt McDaniel on black background

Matt McDaniel

Engineering Project Manager

Merrisa Jennings

Decarbonization Scientist

Headshot of Dr. Peter Psarras on blurred background

Peter Psarras, PhD

Senior Decarbonization Engineer, Life Cycle Assessment

Sanna O'Connor-Morberg

Senior Science and Strategy Manager

Headshot of Sarah Braverman on blurred background

Sarah Braverman

Policy Analyst

Headshot of Thaddeus Woody on orange background

Thaddeus Woody

Policy Analyst

Headshot of Adrianna Sutton

Adrianna Sutton

Science Writer

Becca Morrow

Research Associate

David Lluis Madrid

Research Associate

Liam Kilroy

Research Associate

Mila Stieglitz-Courtney

Research Associate

Shannon Keane

Research Associate

Headshot of Shirin Mavandad

Shirin Mavandad

Research Associate

Headshot of Dr. Amber Kerr on plain gray background

Amber Kerr, PhD

Science Advisor

Headshot of Dr. Claire Nelson on background outside with plants

Claire Nelson, PhD

Science Advisor

Headshot of Dr. Dave Lee on blurred purple background

Dave Lee, PhD

Science Advisor

Headshot of Dr. Dave Ho on blurred background

David Ho, PhD

Science Advisor

Headshot of Dr. Greg Dipple on blurred background

Greg Dipple, PhD

Science Advisor

Headshot of Dr. Jacob Bukoski on background with plants

Jacob Bukoski, PhD

Science Advisor

Jane Zelikova, PhD

Science Advisor

Headshot of Katherine Gomes on blurred background

Katherine Gomes

Science Advisor

Headshot of Dr. Lauren Gifford on blurred background

Lauren Gifford, PhD

Science Advisor

Headshot of Dr. Niall Mac Dowell on blurred background

Niall Mac Dowell, PhD

Science Advisor

Headshot of Dr. Pete Smith on gray background

Pete Smith, PhD

Science Advisor

Headshot of Dr. Tiffany Troxler outside with green background

Tiffany Troxler, PhD

Science Advisor

Headshot of Elisse Roche on blurred purple background

Elisse Roche

Senior Marketing Manager

Headshot of Maria Mendieta on blurred background

Maria Mendieta

Director of Product